•  
  •  
 

Abstract

Animal sentience is a leading justification for animal legal rights, reflected in academic debate and in national laws such as the United Kingdom’s Animal Welfare (Sentience) Act 2022. This Note argues that sentience alone is an inadequate justification and must be paired with Professor Martha Nussbaum’s debt-from-human-harm theory. The sentience theory cannot explain why some species, such as dogs and pandas, receive greater protection than pigs, which are no less sentient. Because sentience is fixed by species, the theory implies a hierarchy of sentience and a species-specific ceiling on rights, even though differential protection often depends on cultural and economic factors. Its focus on pain also limits protection to pain avoidance. The harm theory instead protects animals harmed by human consumption, development, and control, and by environmental damage. Integrating both theories, this Note constructs a progressive right to feasible alternatives that reduce harm, supported by international environmental law’s requirement to improve and non-regression principle.

Share

COinS