Abstract
Since 2008, the United States, Canada, and the federated polities therein have pursed a multilateral and binding suite of legislation and adjudications surrounding water use in the Laurentian Great Lakes basin aimed at limiting diversions. Meanwhile, rates of unsustainable urban development have continued to increase in western North America as the surface water and aquifers necessary to ensure such development dwindle among the effects of the climate crisis and western megadrought. While American and Canadian lawmakers seek to alleviate the challenges posed by western water insecurity, stakeholders within the Great Lakes basin have grown continually anxious, fearing western speculators will seize precious Great Lakes water to ensure continued profits from development. This article explores the relationship between protectionist Great Lakes water regulations and increasing water insecurity of western North America. It outlines the history of Great Lakes and western water governance, evaluates threats posed to the Great Lakes from beyond the basin, and proposes alternatives to alleviate the mounting pressure between Great Lakes stakeholders and water insecure jurisdictions. This article will evaluate whether Great Lakes water is truly in peril as some intra-basin environmentalists fear, consider the role protectionist water policies play in that purported insecurity, and ponder the feasibility of a solidarity-ethic aimed at reducing insecurity and fostering a shared commitment to environmental preservation that supports sustainable, collective, and collaborative development.
While humans have thrived in unforgiving terrains for millennia, no civilization can exist without freshwater. Water is integral to human life. Humans also ascribe symbolic meaning to their surroundings, building identities around the environments they love. Individuals and cultures consider themselves guardians of precious natural resources to which they ascribe personalities and anthropologic feelings. These understandings are sometimes recognized in North American law but are more often identifiable within the hearts of activists to whom these environments are sacred. This paper reconciles the legal, philosophical, and sentimental provisions surrounding Great Lakes governance and applies the scholarship of Elinor Ostrom, Sheila R. Foster, and Wallace Stegner to North American water insecurity both within and beyond the Laurentian Great Lakes basin to propose a new solidarity-minded water use ethic to safeguard the land and the people it supports in the most equitable and sustainable way possible.
Recommended Citation
Skakun, John. M. (2026) "The Efficiency of International Efforts and Legal Alternatives to Protect the Laurentian Great Lakes and Alleviate North American Water Insecurity in Our Warming World," Environmental and Earth Law Journal (EELJ): Vol. 12 : Iss. 1 , Article 6.
Included in
Administrative Law Commons, Environmental Law Commons, Land Use Law Commons, Law and Society Commons, Natural Resources Law Commons
